Discover
/
Article

J. J. Thomson and the Bohr atom

APR 01, 1977
Far from being merely “scientific curiosities,” J. J. Thomson’s seemingly naive models actually contained some of the fundamental ideas of Niels Bohr’s revolutionary quantum theory of the atom.
John L. Heilbron

In 1911 Niels Bohr went to Cambridge, hoping to talk physics with J. J. Thomson; the discoverer of the electron was friendly but uninterested. Two years later Bohr published his epochal three‐part paper on the constitution of atoms and molecules, which challenged the program and goal of the Cambridge school. Bohr’s new views soon won out; Thomson’s quaint atomic models were declared worthless—old lumber fit only, as Ernest Rutherford put it, “for a museum of scientific curiosities.” For his part Thomson rejected the advances made by Bohr as meretricious superficialities obtained without, or at the price of, an understanding of the mechanism of atoms.

This article is only available in PDF format

More about the Authors

John L. Heilbron. University of California, Berkeley.

Related content
/
Article
Figuring out how to communicate with the public can be overwhelming. Here’s some advice for getting started.
/
Article
Amid growing investment in planetary-scale climate intervention strategies that alter sunlight reflection, global communities deserve inclusive and accountable oversight of research.
/
Article
Although motivated by the fundamental exploration of the weirdness of the quantum world, the prizewinning experiments have led to a promising branch of quantum computing technology.
/
Article
As conventional lithium-ion battery technology approaches its theoretical limits, researchers are studying alternative architectures with solid electrolytes.
This Content Appeared In
pt-cover_1977_04.jpeg

Volume 30, Number 4

Get PT in your inbox

pt_newsletter_card_blue.png
PT The Week in Physics

A collection of PT's content from the previous week delivered every Monday.

pt_newsletter_card_darkblue.png
PT New Issue Alert

Be notified about the new issue with links to highlights and the full TOC.

pt_newsletter_card_pink.png
PT Webinars & White Papers

The latest webinars, white papers and other informational resources.

By signing up you agree to allow AIP to send you email newsletters. You further agree to our privacy policy and terms of service.