arXiv screening process called into question
FEB 01, 2016
DOI: 10.1063/PT.5.029540
Nature : Nicolas Gisin of the University of Geneva has accused moderators at the arXiv eprint server of blacklisting two of his graduate students. The accusation stems from moderators’ refusing to publish two papers submitted by the students. Although the first paper was admittedly controversial, the second was less so. When Gisin asked for an explanation, the moderators refused to provide one. Gisin says that arXiv unfairly dismissed the second paper based on the controversial nature of the first. The accusation has spurred other scientists to push for more transparency in the archive’s screening process.
© 2016 American Institute of Physics
