More about tachyons

DEC 01, 1969

Not so fast! say critics of the May article in which Bilaniuk and Sudarshan offered the arguments for faster-than-light particles. Their letters raise questions about causality and interactions. The original authors contribute a reply.

DOI: 10.1063/1.3035294

Olexa-Myron Bilaniuk

Stephen L. Brown

Bryce DeWitt

William A. Newcomb

Mendel Sachs

E. C. George Sudarshan

Shoichi Yoshikawa

“Anything that is not forbidden is compulsory,” says Murray Gell-Mann’s half-facetious totalitarian principle. What then about faster-than-light particles called “tachyons”? In their May article Olexa-Myron Bilaniuk and E. C. George Sudarshan argued that valid solutions of Albert Einstein’s relativity equations describe such particles. Thus if Einstein’s equations are accurate descriptions of the physical universe and if solutions not forbidden are compulsory, tachyons must exist.

References

1. O. M. Bilaniuk, E. C. G. Sudarshan, PHYSICS TODAY 22, no. 5, 43 (1969).https://doi.org/PHTOAD
2. O. M. P. Bilaniuk, V. K. Deshpande, E. C. G. Sudarshan, Am. J. Phys. 30, 718 (1962).https://doi.org/AJPIAS
3. C. A. Hurst, Math. Rev. 26, 667 (1963).https://doi.org/MAREAR
4. T. Alväger, J. Blomqvist, P. Erman, 1963 Annual Report of the Nobel Research Institute, Stockholm, pp. 95–97.
5. G. Feinberg, Phys. Rev. 159, 1089 (1967).https://doi.org/PHRVAO
6. A. C. Clark, The Promise of Space, Harper & Row, New York (1968), p. 299.
7. R. C. Tolman, The Theory of Relativity of Motion, University of California Press, Berkeley (1917), p. 54.
8. D. Bohm, Special Theory of Relativity, W. A. Benjamin, New York, 1965, pp. 155–160.
9. G. A. Benford, D. L. Book, W. A. Newcomb, Lawrence Radiation Laboratory Report UCRL-71789, Livermore, (1969).
10. R. Fox, C. G. Kuper, S. G. Lipson, Nature 223, 597 (1969).https://doi.org/NATUAS
11. A. Sommerfeld, Physics Z. 8, 841 (1907);
L. Brillouin, Ann. Physik 44, 203 (1914).https://doi.org/ANPYA2
12. R. Skinner, Relativity, Blaisdell Publishing Co, Waltham, Mass (1969), p. 189.
13. R. G. Newton, Phys. Rev. 162, 1274 (1967).https://doi.org/PHRVAO
14. P. L. Csonka, Phys. Rev. 180, 1266 (1969).https://doi.org/PHRVAO
15. W. B. Rolnick, Phys. Rev. 85, 1105 (1969).https://doi.org/PHRVAO
16. B. Maglic et al., Bull. Am. Phys. Soc. 14, 840, (1969).https://doi.org/BAPSA6
17. C. Baltay, G. Feinberg, N. Weh, R. Linsker, US AEC Report NYO-1932 (2)-148 (1969).
18. J. W. Rhee, Technical Report No. 70-025, Center for Theoretical Physics, University of Maryland (1969).

More about the Authors

Olexa-Myron Bilaniuk. Swarthmore College.

Stephen L. Brown. Stanford Research Institute.

Bryce DeWitt. University of North Carolina.

William A. Newcomb. Livermore Laboratory.

Mendel Sachs. State University of New York, Buffalo.

E. C. George Sudarshan. University of Texas, Austin.

Shoichi Yoshikawa. Princeton University.